Our pitch

 Pitch A: Relationship full of secrets when the wife gets a strange secret. 

Pitch B:2 archeologists go to an ancient site for observation, however things take a turn. 

Discuss pitch A: We found this interesting as it instantly hit with an idea. The idea with that was a serial killer hiding in plain sight and his wife who's a nurse with a new influx of patients sharing strange symptoms. However this plot held limited creative freedom. Additionally it didn't fit with all of our groups ideas, not everyone could get what they wanted in a way that fit for everyone. While it was a fun and creative topic it just wasn't as strong as it could be.

Discuss pitch B:This idea had such a vivid movie flow, immediately we were all bouncing ideas and ended up coming up with a full movie plot. It'd be a fun film to produce not only because of the creative flow, also because of the magnificence of it. It'd be quite easy to film and the fashions would quite diverse. Along with interesting characters & cast. Along with interesting characters, such as Pharaohs which would be part of a sci-fi element.

Final choice: We choose to go with the second pitch on archeology as it had a grad creative flow and felt... right!